REVIEW PAPER
TREATY CAPACITY OF THE DEPENDENT STATES IN THE LIGHT OF THE WORK OF THE UN COMMISSION ON INTERNATIONAL LAW
More details
Hide details
1
Wojskowa Akademia Techniczna im. Jarosława Dąbrowskiego w Warszawie
Publication date: 2017-12-01
SBN 2017;12(2): 209-227
KEYWORDS
ABSTRACT
The submitted article concerns the issue of the treaty capacity of the dependent states, which was considered in the course of the work of the UN International Law Commission (UNCCP) on the draft convention on the law of treaties. And although today this term does not apply to the international community consisting of sovereign states, at the time when the preparatory work of the UN KPM was underway, which began in 1949 and continued for the next seventeen years, the concept of dependent states was widely used. Well, at least that was the beginning of this process. This article presents the changes to the regulation on the treaty capacity of the dependent states contained in the drafts prepared by the four successive rapporteurs of the Commission who were entrusted with the task of drafting a convention on the law of treaties. This issue was important because sometimes the dependent states had the ability to conclude treaties independently, regardless of the treaty capacity of the state responsible for conducting their foreign affairs. The discussed issue seems to be of particular interest in comparison with the process of decolonization at that time, supported, inter alia, by the declaration of the United Nations General Assembly of 1960 on granting independence to colonial states and nations (Resolution 1514). Since then, the coexistence of equal and sovereign states (including those emerged as a result of decolonization) has been the basis for maintaining international peace and security under the supervision of the UN Security Council. The notion of a "dependent state" therefore had to be finally rejected in the ILC's draft work. The Commission recognized that states must be sovereign and, as such, have treaty capacity. This solution was then upheld in the laconic disposition of Art. 6 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties of 1969 (KPT), according to which each state has the capacity to conclude treaties. According to the KPT, the term "state" within the meaning of this convention has the same meaning as, inter alia, in the Charter of the United Nations, i.e. as a state in the meaning of international law, or as a state in the international meaning of the term.
REFERENCES (8)
1.
A/RES/1514/XV, Deklaracja w sprawie przyznania niepodległości krajom i narodom kolonialnym,
http://www.grocjusz.edu.pl/Doc... 2 A/RES/3233/XXIX. Participation in the Convention on Special Missions, its Optional Protocolconcerning the Compulsory Settlement of Disputes and the Vienna Convention on the Lawof Treaties. (
http://research.un.org/en/docs...) 3 Case concerning rights of nationals of the United States of America in Morocco, Judgmentof August 27 th, 1952, I.C. J. Reports 1952, s.176 i n. 4 International Law Commission Yearbook (ILC Yearbook), lata: 1950-53, 1956, 1962, 1965,1966. 5 Konwencja wiedeńska o prawie traktatów sporządzona w Wiedniu dnia 23 maja 1969 r. (tekstpolski, Dz.U. z 1991 r., Nr 74, poz. 439). 6 Konwencja wiedeńska o stosunkach dyplomatycznych z 1961 roku (tekst polski, Dz.U. z 1965r., Nr 37, poz. 232), 7 Konwencja wiedeńska o stosunkach konsularnych z 1963 roku (tekst polski, Dz.U z 1982 r.,nr 13, poz. 98). 1 Czapliński W., Wyrozumska A., Prawo międzynarodowe publiczne. Zagadnienia systemowe,Warszawa 2014, wyd. 3.
2.
Góralczyk W., Sawicki S., Prawo międzynarodowe publiczne w zarysie, Wyd.16, Warszawa2015.
3.
Karski K., Kamiński T., Treaty-Making Capacity of Components of Federal States from the Perspectiveof the Works of the UN International Law Commission, Polish Review of Internationaland European Law, vol. 5, Issue 2 (2016), s. 9-43.
4.
Karski K., Zasięg podmiotowy Konwencji wiedeńskiej o prawie traktatów, [w:] 40 lat minęło– praktyka i perspektywy Konwencji Wiedeńskiej o prawie traktatów, Z. Galicki, T. Kamiński,K. Myszona-Kostrzewa (red.), Warszawa 2009, s. 53-88.
5.
Makowski J., Prawo międzynarodowe, Warszawa 1922, wyd. II uzupełnione.
6.
Nahlik S.E., Kodeks prawa traktatów, Warszawa 1976.
7.
Nahlik S.E., Wstęp do nauki prawa międzynarodowego, Warszawa 1967.
8.
Szafarz R., Konferencja i Konwencja wiedeńska dotyczące prawa traktatów – w moich wspomnieniach– 1968 i 1969 rok, [w:] 40 lat minęło – praktyka i perspektywy Konwencji Wiedeńskiejo prawie traktatów, Z. Galicki, T. Kamiński, K. Myszona-Kostrzewa (red.), Warszawa 2009,s. 17-21.